what lies beyond jay miller?

Monday, December 05, 2011

Dr. Vino (and other sources) are reporting that Robert Parker has announced that Jay Miller will no longer be writing for The Wine Advocate. The usual blather about what a great job Miller has done, is followed by the mandatory denial that his sudden departure has anything to do with the current scandal regarding pay to play reviews in Spain.

My only interest in any of this is how it will impact the wineries of the Pacific Northwest. According to the report I read, David Schildknecht will now review the wines of Oregon and Washington.

I have never met Schildknecht, but I have read his reviews in The Wine Advocate over the years and as far as his writing skills and (apparent) palate mastery are concerned, he is light years beyond Miller. I don’t hold any hope that Washington and Oregon will ever occupy a particularly important place in the Advocate scheme of things, and to my knowledge, Schildknecht has never set foot in the region.

But I would hope, until proven wrong, that he will approach these wines without prejudice, and return some reasonably critical thinking to the reviews. Although the point escalation under Miller has been excessive, there is no reason that a more informed and thoughtful critic couldn’t pull back a little, and start to write reviews that reflect the true strengths of the region.

I will look forward to seeing what develops, and if Mr. Schildknecht happens to read this blog, I would invite him to contact me if I can be of any assistance.


kevin keith said...


I've known David for years and consider him a huge influence on my career and my so-called writing. David has an unparalleled wealth of knowledge and I believe him to be one of the most experienced and intelligent souls in the wine biz. I have no doubt the wines of Washington and Oregon will impress him as they have myself, probably more so. The wine industry in your neighborhood will be profoundly blessed to have him covering that beat.

Nicolas said...


I do welcome the news because I felt that reviews were a bit biased under Mr Miller's tenure (trying to stay PC). I am concerned about the vast region that Mr Schildnecht has to cover now - how can he do all that? On the positive, Mr Schildnecht reviews Germany and is a great Riesling fan so it will be interesting to see if he can bring something to our region by his insight and be a good ambassador of our wines.


Stephanie LaMonica said...

pardon my naivete, but why would Schildnecht approach OR and WA wines with prejudice? and what flavor would that prejudice be, anyway?

PaulG said...

Stephanie, I was expressing a hope, not a fear. I do not know the man, and have no clue what his palate preferences and/or prejudices may be. But I have seen a sharp deterioration in the quality of the Advocate's NW coverage, and I sense that Mr. Parker is not especially interested in this region. Prejudice can be very similar to neglect.

Post a Comment

Your comment is awaiting moderation and will be posted ASAP. Thanks!